Preserving the Railroad: A Mistake to Sacrifice the Catskill Mountain Railroad for Only Rail Trails

Ulster Strong opposes the recent proposal to close the beloved Catskill Mountain Railroad (CMRR) in favor of expanding our rail trail network. Over the past few years, the CMRR has become a vital part of our community, attracting 60,000 riders and emerging as a key tourist destination in Kingston and Ulster County. This surge in ridership illustrates not only strong market demand but also the management's capability to grow and thrive.

The CMRR provides a distinctive, immersive experience that allows the public to connect with an important chapter of local and national history. It stands in contrast to a rail trail: the CMRR generates no cost to taxpayers, creates jobs, and contributes significantly to our local tax base through revenue from visitors outside our community. Furthermore, it pays the county for leasing the land continuously, ensuring a steady income stream. By comparison, the proposed rail trail would demand an initial investment of over $15 million, alongside ongoing maintenance costs, while also resulting in lost revenue from shutting down the train.

The CMRR has proven its ability to forge strong partnerships with local businesses, enhancing community connections across diverse groups and fostering a sense of unity.

While Ulster Strong advocates for investments in our rail trail system, we believe that future expansions should not jeopardize thriving and distinctive local enterprises. Eliminating a successful revenue-generating and job-creating asset like the CMRR would not only be a grave mistake but also send a detrimental message: that Ulster County is not a place conducive to business and innovation. Let us stand together to protect the CMRR and the economic vitality it brings to our community.